18 Advanced Direct Mail Strategies to Drive Incredible Results

Today’s top DTC marketers treat postcards like targeted missiles, precisely reaching customers with creativity and accuracy. 

The results? 

High ROI, boosted revenue, strong net-new acquisition, and re-engaged customers.

Let’s go beyond basic postcard blasts and dive into advanced direct mail strategies brands like KURU, HexClad, and Taylor Stitch use to drive real results.

Automated Trigger-Based Postcards: Set, Automate, Profit

Forget one-off blasts. 

The real strength of programmatic direct mail is in automated campaigns triggered by customer behaviors. Check ‘em out…

• Cart Abandonment Postcards (above): Footwear brand KURU automatically sends postcards via PostPilot’s MailMatch™ to cart abandoners after six days, generating over $60K in sales.
• Win-Back Campaigns: Taylor Stitch uses automated postcards targeting customers inactive for 90 days—often without discounts—and sees 10x+ ROAS.

• Targeting churned subscribers (above): For subscription brands, postcards can serve as an incredible anti-churn superpower, bringing dozens of people (and super profitable revenue) back.
• Birthday & Anniversary Cards: Red Land Cotton sends automated birthday offers to VIP customers, creating goodwill and incremental sales.

• Post-Purchase Follow-Ups (above): KURU mails postcards 35 and 120 days post-purchase, driving an 11.5× ROAS and boosting repeat purchases significantly.
• Overlapping Automations: HexClad runs many automated retention campaigns, which brought in over $3.2M in revenue at 12x ROAS within one four-month period. These campaigns continuously recover sales that would otherwise vanish, even activating customers who last purchased over a year ago.

Personalization & Segmentation: Make Each Mailer Matter

Direct mail’s power multiplies when personalized and precisely segmented:

• Behavioral Segmentation: Lo & Sons uses purchase history data to cross-promote complementary products, turning one-time buyers into repeat customers.

• ULTRA-VIP Treatment (above): Portland Leather Goods sends unique postcards to its ultra-VIP customers, who they call “Unicorn Whisperers.” These are customers who have spent thousands at the brand. They receive (genuinely) exclusive discounts, product drops, and offers, sent via mail.

• Automating handwritten cards: How often do you receive a personalized note card in the mail? PostPilot’s army of robots hold real pens and write with the nuance of human handwriting. Trigger cards automatically and on demand, writing out individually personalized notes for any reason. Create an unforgettable customer experience for under $2.
• Targeting movers or home buyers: LifeMatch, pt. 2. A new home is like a blank canvas. Whether you just relocated or purchased a house, movers present great opportunities for marketers. Hitting customers with well-timed offers when they’re as primed to purchase as they will ever be… That means a strong ROI for you.
• Hyper Targeted Acquisition: PostPilot’s lookalike audience builder finds high-intent prospects similar to existing customers, significantly improving campaign effectiveness. Caden Lane, a baby apparel brand, achieved 3.8× ROAS using AI-driven targeting.

• Focus on Gift Buyers (above): M&S Meats segmented holiday gifting customers into specific groups, sending tailored postcards to each, resulting in an incredible 10x+ ROI.

• Geotarget customers and drive retail sales (above): Four Sigmatic built a lookalike audience (based on their best Shopify customers) who lived within several miles of a particular Whole Foods location (on N. Lamar Blvd.) in Austin, Texas. These postcards drove 57% higher retail sales vs. the control group.

Integrating Direct Mail with Digital Channels

Direct mail enhances your digital marketing by reaching customers missed by email or digital ads:

• Site Visitor Retargeting (above): Gozney converted anonymous site visitors with postcards, generating $100K+ in sales at a 16x ROI.
• Email Coordination: Combine direct mail with email workflows, sending postcards to customers who don’t engage digitally. WINPRO pet brand boosted responses by mailing to customers who weren’t opening their emails.

• Unified Direct Mail + Email Campaigns (above): HexClad included postcards alongside digital campaigns during Black Friday, contributing significantly to a 66% YoY revenue increase. They added postcards to dynamically trigger at the end of their email/SMS flows, adding a physical layer to their owned strategy.
• SMS Pairing: Send a follow-up SMS after mailing postcards, reinforcing messages and increasing conversions.
• Quiz follow-ups: A neat trick for brands who use a quiz for lead gen and to help customers find the right product for them: if they don’t buy within a couple days, trigger a personalized card based on their answers. This worked like a charm for a cosmetics brand suggesting makeup by skin type. 

With Direct Mail, the Sky’s the Limit

And we can fly you there at PostPilot.

Launch a sophisticated, full-funnel, crazy profitable direct mail program with us by doing almost nothing within ~10 days. 

Your dedicated account manager will handle all the setup and strategy, and our in-house design team will take care of all creative work (just flip us some of your best-performing email assets).

Check us out.

‍